Rehoboth Beach Best Pizza

Best Pizza in Rehoboth Beach

Top 5 Pizza Places in Rehoboth Beach

There are plenty of restaurants in Rehoboth Beach to satisfy any appetite. From fresh seafood and causal beach eats to more upscale cuisine, you can enjoy it all when you visit this coastal community. Despite the array of food offerings, you may want something more classic. You can never go wrong with a delicious slice of pizza.

Rehoboth Beach has several spots that offer a perfectly melted pie. Here are the top five pizza places in Rehoboth Beach, according to Yelp reviewers.

Nicola Pizza

Nicola Pizza is a Rehoboth Beach staple. This family-friendly restaurant has been serving up classic slices, using fresh ingredients, since 1971. Nicola’s sauce and dough contain no animal fat or vegetable oil, making their pies vegetarian-friendly. In addition to pizza, the restaurant is known for its signature “Nic-o-Boli,” an over-stuffed sandwich filled with meat, vegetables, pizza sauce and cheese. Nicola Pizza has two locations in Rehoboth Beach, on Rehoboth Avenue and 1st Street.

Crust & Craft

For crispy artisan pizza, visit Crust & Craft. Located on Coastal Highway, Crust & Craft serves wood-fired pizza, along with pasta and craft beer. The restaurant uses handmade dough for its 12-inch Neapolitan-style pizzas, baked in a wood-fired oven that reaches temperatures of up to 900°F. Diners can choose from signature pizzas such as the P.Y.T., made with cheese, pepperoni and Calabrian chili; Sweet Dreams, made with sweet garlic, mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, parmesan, buffalo mozzarella, thyme and ricotta; and the Philadelphia cheesesteak-inspired pizza, the You Can Take A Fella Outta South Philly.

Crust & Craft Rehoboth Beach

Louie’s Pizza

Louie’s Pizza has been serving Rehoboth Beach locals and visitors for over 40 years. This family-owned pizzeria is just steps away from the Rehoboth Beach Boardwalk, on Rehoboth Avenue. Louie’s is dedicated to sending diners into what they call “pizzavana.” Pizzana is essentially pizza nirvana. Dine inside on a small or large pie, with up to five toppings. Or, take a slice to-go to enjoy right on the beach. All pizzas are made to order so you know you’re getting a fresh, hot pie.

Grotto Pizza

Grotto Pizza is a regional chain that began in Rehoboth Beach in 1960. The restaurant now has over 20 locations across Maryland, Delaware and Pennsylvania, including four in Rehoboth. Enjoy both traditional and signature pizzas, including the Buffalo Chicken pizza, Classic Margherita and even pizza made with gluten-free crust. All of Grotto’s pizzas get a swirl of sauce on top, for a signature look that complements their legendary taste.

Dogfish Head Brewings & Eats

Dogfish Head Brewings & Eats is known for serving up craft beer with delicious dishes. The restaurant’s extensive menu also includes wood-fired pizzas. This isn’t a spot to get just a typical slice. Dogfish Head’s pizzas come with deluxe toppings, such as prosciutto, pesto, exotic mushrooms, crab dip and more. A Day’s Wait pizza even uses cheddar made with the brewery’s own 90 Minute IPA. Stop by Thursday nights during the off season for Dogfish Head’s Wood-Fired Pizza Night. All pizzas from their menu are just $8, including a new hand-crafted specialty pizza each week.

Dogfish Head Brewings & Eats pizza